Uproar – a quote every Wednesday

490: “Imperfections and Incompleteness” (Sarah Travis)

                “I sometimes worry about the imperfections and incompleteness of it all. […] But maybe it’s supposed to feel unfinished […] In that spirit, I am resisting my urge to polish up this letter too much…”
                -Sarah Travis, “Friendship as Scholarship: a Path for Living Inquiry Together,” Experiments in Art Education, p. 178

                Someone told me once that reading the beginning of a novel is like walking into a room and meeting an author who hands you things: here, a description of a fallen tree. Hold this. Here, a child climbing the fallen branches. Here, a quick pair of fluttering wings. The author’s trick (this someone said) is to have the pieces pull together into a story the reader wants to keep reading before the reader gets overwhelmed or bored by what they’re being asked to hold.
                I see what they’re saying, this someone. They’re right sometimes. And sometimes…

                In my teens I started lying awake at night, thinking back over the day to trace out what I had accomplished. What made this day worthwhile. I started doing that for reasons that made good sense at the time, and it might be an interesting practice, sometimes. And sometimes…

                If you were to give me today, if you were to hand over the trees and the fluttering wings and the thoughts that child-me and older-me and our friends are having, apart and together, it wouldn’t make a very clear story. As a reader I might say why are you giving me that. That’s what I mean, sometimes, when I tell my partner at the end of the day wow today feels so long. Going over to feed Jackie’s cats? That was just this morning. There isn’t a nice finished arc to this today-ness. There’s a warm crackling fire. Ash on my hands. A cold, cold wind. Voices. A delicious mouthful of fish. Clothes scattered on the floor. Imperfect and incomplete. Sometimes like my friend Sarah Travis I worry about that, and sometimes like my friend Sarah I celebrate that, because it—whatever it is—is not ending right now. Oh no. It’s snuggling up with blankets. Then it’s dreaming. Who knows after that.

489: “On the floor of the tiny room” (Travis Baldree)

                “Viv lay on the floor of the tiny room. Well, almost on the floor. The place hadn’t been built with orcs in mind, and the bed was too short by at least two feet.”
                -Travis Baldree, Bookshops & Bonedust, p. 6

                That’s how Chapter 1 opens. Later tonight, my partner and I will read that together. Maybe she’ll be listening to my orc-narrator voice. Maybe I’ll be listening to hers. Either way we’ll trade off, curled beneath our blankets as outside the temperature dives below 15℉.
                There’s something tremendously cozy in reading together before bed. Part of it is probably that I grew up reading with my family. Unfolding the story together, walking through it, talking about characters and happenings the next morning before we go back to say hello—all of that for me is a practice of home. And in another way I think home is a practice. I’ve been thinking lately about how strange it is that the structures of my society make it so easy to live next to someone, live with someone, and not feel like you’re in the same room. (That has a lot to do with how my society imagines, builds, and understands rooms, but that’s another post). So my partner and I practice. We fold ourselves into the little space of the book, realize how interwoven it is with sounds and colors and being togethers, and snuggle in.

488: “Conversation With Plants” (Robin Wall Kimmerer)

                “To me, an experiment is a kind of conversation with plants: I have a question for them, but since we don’t speak the same language, I can’t ask them directly and they won’t answer verbally. But plants can be eloquent in their physical responses and behaviors. Plants answer questions by the way they live, by their responses to change; you just need to learn how to ask.”
                
-Robin Wall Kimmerer, Braiding Sweetgrass

                I remember as a kid being so excited about the idea of being able to talk to birds. Some people I knew immediately turned that idea toward a kind of spying—you could ask what so and so was doing, they said—but for me it was more about what the birds might be saying without any direct prompting from me. What were the chirps? The trills? What did they say to each other? How does this bluejay describe her own paths through the air? Does she have names for the trees she lands on, or for individual branches?
                
Looking back, I think part of what I was wanting (or imagining, as a result of shared language) was a greater ability to listen. To learn from, and sometimes simply to participate with, to be in relationship with. I was scared of a dog across the street. But if I knew what it was saying, knew which growls meant stay away and which growls didn’t, I would know more about how to walk near his house. It’s a lovely wish, but it’s also something that I didn’t need the wizardly spells of fantasy novels to do. I think I’ve heard the excited “Food!” of a bluejay standing over a peanut, and I learned something about which of the growls meant stay away. To be connected with is more about time. Spoken language is a way through, but not the only, and there are so many ways of speaking and listening.

487: “The Syrup” & The Sun (Robin Wall Kimmerer)

                “The syrup we pour over pancakes on a winter morning is summer sunshine flowing in golden streams to pool on our plates.” -Robin Wall Kimmerer, Braiding Sweetgrass, p. 86

                It’s gotten cold in Illinois. My love and I covered our little garden of greens, the kale leaves still vibrant (the spinach a little less so, though still lush after our first two frosts), and we’ve started staying warm with our fireplace. That means I’m splitting firewood again like I remember doing as a teen.
                I love how splitting firewood and planting kale, spinach, and arugula (I can’t leave out those deliciously spicy friends) brings me back to a being-ness and moving-ness of the world. It’s different, for me, when I move the thermostat and a distant hum indicates a furnace that I don’t know how to fix or feed has started. When I started imagining writing this post, I was worried I didn’t have a new thought. Not really. And I don’t think I have, not really, but this isn’t a thought-post. Syrup is summer sunshine. Kimmerer’s line comes from a chapter on making maple syrup. The heat that moves around me is always something: a dance that stepped along before (as gas or electricity or a tree’s reaching branches) and will keep stepping along (out through the front door, and in through me, too, come to think of it). This is a post about being with that being-ness. About recognizing the ways my habits pull me away from the roots of kale and the grain of wood and the bugs, I don’t know their name, who’ve been nibbling from the same plants I’m nibbling. About relishing the practices that bring me back. Whsh. Thunk. I wish I could end this with the sound of an axe landing, or with the touch of dirt, cool and close.

486: “This Tab” (L. D. Lewis)

                “I’ve had this tab open for maybe a month now.”
                -L. D. Lewis, in the “A Note from the Editor” for We’re Here

                Lately I’m entranced by in-process moments. By the pauses in practices, sometimes calm and quiet. A step outside before washing the dishes. Sometimes hurried and harried, mental gears grinding. The bus ten minutes late and me already worried about getting to a meeting on time. Which is to say, like L. D. Lewis, I tend to leave a lot of tabs open. Some of them are projects I’m working on. Some of them are things I’d like to read, sometime. One of them’s a TV show I’m partway through. And yes, for me, there’s something about hurrying in that, something about a messy feeling where I can’t seem to finish x before I start y. But then again what I’m doing isn’t usually x or y: specific projects and relationships aren’t variables, they’re all the context and nuance of particularities, delights, sometimes confusions. That article I’m partway through reading, the ideas are still turning, rooting down, and the why takes time.
                Which is to say: lately, with so much going on, I’ve been trying to finish things. Knock items off the To-Do List. Sitting with L. D. Lewis, I realize my To-Do Lists don’t know how to list the confusion of a thought half held. A movement still mellowing. How do I listen to more of the open spaces inside what I’m doing?

485: “Okay bring it in” (Jinkx Monsoon)

                “Okay. Okay bring it in.”
                -Jinkx Monsoon, in a quick aside while singing “One Day More” from Les Misérables

                More than a year ago, a friend and I tried to follow a creek that runs through the neighborhoods where we lived. Some of the creek’s beneath housing developments just now, pushed down into what I assume are cement pipes. Other portions are landscaped, curated: that’s how it is near the Engineering Quad on campus. Pretty walkways and bridges. Other portions of the creek are confined in these deep channels, and we put our heads over the fences, looking down. As we followed the current we kept running into roads with no walkways, into paved places where you couldn’t tell where the creek was, into no trespassing signs from the National Guard. It would’ve been fun to follow the creek past city limits, but we turned back at those signs.
                I love when singers spin around the genre for a song lots of people know. “Hot’n’cold” as polka. “Defying Gravity” as funk. I love when someone tries out a different kind of singing, and we get to listen, cheering them on. I think it’s partly because Jinkz Monsoon is so playfully inhabiting different genres, different performances, of being human: she’s playing back into the steps and hips rolls and shoulder wiggles that are supposed to be “him” or “her,” supposed to define the social persona in which someone walks along as a barkeep or a detective or a lover. It reminds me a little of the creek pushed into so many shapes by the construction projects of Urbana, IL. And  the water flowing along, down from clouds, out into prairies, not held by our shapes (not really, not forever). Dancing. I hope I’ll get to go back and continue that walk.

484: “I” (Jenny Davis)

                Nine months ago I talked with the wonderful faculty of my PhD Committee for my PhD Fields Exam. We talked about lots of things, including some of the community organizing work I facilitate. And I said something like, “It’s hard for me to say ‘I do this’ and ‘I do that’ to organize things, because everything I do is woven through with what so many other powerful people are doing. And there’s a long history of people (especially white men) saying I did this as a way to take credit for or hide all the other work that other wonderful people are doing. The work they themselves are relying on.”
                Jenny Davis, a Chickasaw scholar, poet, and educator, told me that was one way people use “I.” Another way is to say Here I am. Here is my place in my communities. Here I recognize and choose to live up to the responsibilities and duties of our interwoven lives. I’ve been thinking about that ever since. What I’m sitting with today, what I’m wondering about and mourning and, yes, celebrating, goes all the way down to what I mean by “I.” What we might mean by “we.” Because here I am, and I choose to work to recognize and live up to the responsibilities and duties that flow through this wonderful web of living things of which I’m a part. That can feel heavy. That can feel joyous. That’s the “I” I practice.

484: “Your Strangest and Funniest Friend” (Dave Eggers & Amanda Uhle)

                “Find your strangest and funniest friend. Have that strange friend find their funniest and strangest friend.” -Dave Eggers & Amanda Uhle, Introducing Unnecessarily Beautiful Spaces for Young Minds on Fire

                This is going to be a little all over the place, because you know when a child comes running up to you because there’s a cat outside and the cat was climbing a tree and my friend climbs trees and we love plums and did I tell you we’re building a spaceship that might be a garden? Were you that kid, sometimes? Are you still?
                Today my friend Jackie and I were sitting at a table, enjoying the breath of a gentle breeze and squinting through bright electric lights, and trying to work. It happens sometimes. She was working on an application for funding, which would help make possible some of her wildly cool research. I was trying to read Aja Martinez’s Counterstory, also wildly cool, and important for a journal article I’m revising. It’s all work we believe in. And we just didn’t want to do it. Our snacks had helped, fueling a few more keystrokes, but all the snacks were gone.
                So Jackie showed me Nael’s “The Tiger.” You might’ve seen it before—a spark of a little poem, and it jumped through all sorts of social media a couple years ago. The author’s a child. The poem’s full of a wild, brave, world-making excitement. “The Tiger” was published in a collection edited by 826DC, a very cool place that I’m definitely not reading more about (instead of doing my other work). I didn’t know this strange friend but I immediately recognized them as friends with 826 Valencia—a very cool someone, if you haven’t met them, and probably worth some not-reading of your own. And we do love plums. And there is a cat outside. And sometimes in learning from children (of all ages, 6 and 25 and 92) I remember that I’m a strange friend who loves my strange friends and that together we’re definitely making something.

483: “And Watched The Heart” (Aliette de Bodard)

                “Thuỷ stood in her cabin in The Goby in the Well, her bots arrayed on her shoulders and clinging to her wrists, and watched the heart of the nebula.”
                -Aliette de Bodard, “Mulberry and Owl,” We’re Here (and also here in Uncanny Magazine)

                I almost always write about a quote from something I’ve finished reading. Or at least, I often think of it that way, which is weird, because I’ve never actually finished reading any of the stories that I love most. They swirl and come back, less single events and more waves & eddies & seaspray & quick sips & long drinks. In any case, tonight, I’m thinking about de Bodard’s line because I’m just starting to read “Mulberry and the Owl.” Half a page in something pulled me away. And there’s something lovely about story beginnings, something that connects to why I like fiction and speculative fiction in particular.
                Years ago I heard Stanford neuroendocrinologist Robert Sapolsky lecture about human interest in “newness.” One of his suggestions was that an individual’s interest in newness tends to wear out overtime— if an American hadn’t tried sushi by their early twenties, his research found, the odds were they never would. If they didn’t have a piercing by their early twenties the odds were they never would. Similarly his research indicated that Americans tend to set their taste in music by their teens or weary twenties. One interesting nuance: Zapolsky said that if you set out to be a beginner in anything—pick up the harp, which you have no idea how to play, and deeply start learning—your interest in newness across the board tends to go up. A regular, purposeful practice of being a beginner brings you back to new beginnings.
                Like short story opening lines. Like all opening lines, maybe, if you read them that way. I start reading and I’m a beginner in this world, because Thuỷ has bots arrayed on her arm. (What kind of bots, I wonder?). Because I’ve never looked at the heart of any nebula. (What does Thuỷ see?). Because reading this I’m listening, wondering: who is this? What community web do they live in? What matters to them, and as we gaze into this nebula, what’s possible?

482: “All The Water” of Us (Sayaka Murata)

                “‘[…] there’s a different air about you.’”
                […] Yukari was right I thought. After all, I absorbed the world around me, and that’s changing all the time. Just as all the water that was in my body last time we met has now been replaced with new water, the things that make up me have changed too. When we last met a few years ago, most of the store workers were laid-back university students, so of course my way of speaking was different then.
                ‘I guess. Yes, I have probably changed,’ I said with a smile, not elaborating.” – Sayaka Murata, Convenience Store Woman

                Earlier today my sister-in-law, Fa, and I ended up chatting over the different ways we see ourselves in our friends and family. She told me about meeting one of her roommate’s sisters: “Just wait,” the roommate said, “meeting my sister is going tell you so much about me.” And it did. In their mannerisms, their phrases, their playfulness, Fa recognized the sisters by seeing them together.
                I often feel that way. There’s a kind of American individualism that’s really attached to an inner, essential, solitary self, and I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about that—but sitting here now, what I feel is the wash of water as different people fill me. My parents, of course, and my siblings. Even from thousands of miles away I was looking at a palm tree today, and the way I looked at it came in part from my dad. I said hello to someone who passed and my mom’s phrasing washed through me. And then there’s my spouse, my spouse’s siblings, my friends, the other people I meet. In the last few days I’ve met a lot of my partner’s cousins, uncles, and aunts, and already I hear new phrases on my tongue. I find myself making new jokes. It’s fun.
                I used to love jumping into puddles. The splash. The reflection. The game. I’d stand and watch the changing water, too, the rippling tree branches and the sky. Sitting here I splash and reflect and play, my own little puddle self. Smiling, just like Sayaka Murata’s character.